# Croaking Counterpart Croaking Counterpart appeals to collectors interested in Innistrad's frog token theme and clone effects. The card represents a niche mechanical space—a creature-copying spell with a specific tribal identity—that resonates with players building around creature types. Collectors typically value it for set completion rather than broader appeal, since it occupies a narrow design space within limited and casual formats. The nonfoil and foil variants exist as standard printings. Neither variant commands particular collector premium beyond typical foil markup, as the card lacks the iconic status or scarcity that drives secondary market demand. It remains a straightforward rare for those systematizing their Innistrad: Midnight Hunt collections.